Shrewsbury has the UK’s second-best-rated high street, according to new research into more than four million Google reviews of UK shops by Birmingham SEO company OKPromo (https://okpromo.co.uk/), with Hereford not far behind as Christmas shopping gets under way.

Shops in Shrewsbury town centre average 4.54 stars out of five, second only to Lancaster on 4.55 among the 135 UK town and city centres in the study. Only 8% of Shrewsbury’s shops are rated below four stars, against 17% across the UK. Hereford is fifth on 4.49, while Telford’s shops come 105th on 4.26.

In Shrewsbury, 78% of the latest reviews of its shops give five stars, and almost half of the comments (48%) praise friendly or helpful staff. One shopper wrote in a five-star review of a shop in Shrewsbury in June 2026, “The staff were lovely from start to finish, and gave a really personal service.”

Another wrote in a five-star review of a shop in Hereford in May 2026, “I had a lovely time browsing and buying a shirt the staff were very friendly and helpful they also retrieved my favourite cap from the pub next door and posted it back to me”.

Across the UK, Ilford and Portsmouth are joint bottom on 4.08 stars out of five, with Harrow a fraction above them, while Lancaster has the best-rated high street on 4.55, ahead of Shrewsbury and Perth. The average shop in the study scores 4.35, and 17% of shops are rated below four stars.

Shops belonging to big chains, the 183 names found in at least eight of the towns, average 4.20 stars, against 4.50 for independents and smaller groups, and the chains come out lower in 133 of the 135 centres.

Cristian Constantin, SEO expert at OKPromo, said, “The towns at the top are packed with independent shops where the person serving you often owns the business, and you can see it in the reviews, which keep mentioning friendly, helpful staff. The big chains still score well, but independents edge ahead in almost every town we looked at, so a high street with plenty of independents starts with an advantage.”

Cristian added, “When someone searches for gifts nearby, Google shows the star rating next to every shop’s name, so a strong score can bring in people who have never walked down that street. People who have a bad experience are far more likely to leave a review than people who have a good one, so asking happy customers to leave a review at the till is one of the easiest things a shop can do this Christmas. Replying to the ones that come in shows there is a real person behind the counter.”

How Shropshire and Herefordshire’s high streets rank

  1. Shrewsbury, 2nd of 135, 4.54 stars across 91 shops
  2. Hereford, 5th of 135, 4.49 stars across 78 shops
  3. Telford, 105th of 135, 4.26 stars across 66 shops

How the research was done

  1. The places: 135 UK town and city centres. These are the ONS’s major towns and cities in England and Wales, with London split into 15 main shopping districts, plus every other UK city and Paisley and East Kilbride. Places with fewer than 40 qualifying shops were left out.
  2. The shops: on 13 November 2026, OKPromo searched Google Maps in each centre for 12 kinds of shop people use for Christmas shopping. These were clothes, shoes, gifts, toys, books, jewellery, beauty, electronics, homeware, sports, department stores and general shops. Only shops with at least 20 Google reviews within 1 km of the centre’s busiest cluster of shops were counted. Supermarkets and food shops, cafĂ©s, hairdressers, opticians, repair shops, furniture and DIY stores and shopping centre listings were left out. That left 13,433 shops with 4.16 million reviews. Each search returns up to 100 shops, so the biggest centres are covered by a large sample rather than every shop.
  3. The score: each centre’s score is the average Google star rating of its shops, worked out exactly from each shop’s star counts. Every shop counts the same, however many reviews it has. Ties are split on the unrounded figure. The ratings cover each shop’s reviews over time, not just this Christmas.
  4. The complaints: for every shop in Ilford, Portsmouth, Harrow and Solihull, up to 20 of its lowest-rated reviews were read. The 3,189 one and two-star reviews with a comment were sorted by what they complained about, and one review can mention more than one thing. 1,768 of them were written in the last two years.
  5. The quotes: shoppers’ words are quoted exactly as written. For the best-rated towns quoted, the 10 newest reviews of every shop were read, and for the other lowest-rated towns quoted, up to 20 of each shop’s lowest-rated reviews. The Lancaster and Shrewsbury figures come from those newest reviews.
  6. Chains: the 183 brand names found in at least eight of the towns were counted as chains.

No shop is named in the research. The full ranking of all 135 centres and a chart for each region are available on request.

The UK’s 10 lowest-rated high streets

  1. Ilford, London, 4.08 stars across 85 shops
  2. Portsmouth, 4.08 stars across 59 shops
  3. Harrow, London, 4.08 stars across 60 shops
  4. Uxbridge, London, 4.15 stars across 56 shops
  5. Solihull, 4.15 stars across 75 shops
  6. Stratford, London, 4.15 stars across 162 shops
  7. Ealing, London, 4.15 stars across 58 shops
  8. Sutton, London, 4.15 stars across 64 shops
  9. West Bromwich, 4.17 stars across 52 shops
  10. Bromley, London, 4.17 stars across 103 shops

The UK’s 10 best-rated high streets

  1. Lancaster, 4.55 stars across 69 shops
  2. Shrewsbury, 4.54 stars across 91 shops
  3. Perth, 4.52 stars across 79 shops
  4. Sheffield, 4.50 stars across 115 shops
  5. Hereford, 4.49 stars across 78 shops
  6. Cheltenham, 4.48 stars across 118 shops
  7. Chester, 4.48 stars across 141 shops
  8. York, 4.47 stars across 197 shops
  9. Brighton, 4.47 stars across 280 shops
  10. Derry, 4.46 stars across 71 shops